Dealing with COVID-19 in the towns and cities of the global South_International Institute for Environment and Development


Dealing with COVID-19 in the towns and cities of the global South_International Institute for Environment and Development



1 Page 1

▲back to top


07/04/2020
Dealing with COVID-19 in the towns and cities of the global South | International Institute for Environment and Development
lied
Our work “About News and comment Publications
Urban > Coronavirus
Search
Dealing with COVID-19 in the towns and cities of
the global South
Diana Mitlin looks at the particular challenges the COVID-19 outbreak will pose to
people living in informal settlements, what steps can be taken to reach the populations in
need, and how community organisation networks can be supported to scale up their
efforts.
Blog by Diana Mitlin
27 March 2020
@DianaMitlin
eae (eeeee. yap
rear
a et 1
7 i,
a
a.
om
7
ai ia
The densely packed favelas of Rio de Janeiro, climb into the mountains. Brazil President Jair Bolsonaro has
caused confusion with public comments on the coronavirus that have contradicted the global consensus as well
as his own health officials (Photo: Chris Jones, via Flickr, CC BY-NC 2.0)
The global spread of COVID-19 poses particular risks for the one billion people living in informal
urban settlements in the global South. A range of factors make transition of the virus more likely and
https:/Avww.iied.org/dealing-covid-19-towns-cities-global-south
1/8

2 Page 2

▲back to top


07/04/2020
Dealing with COVID-19 in the towns and cities of the global South | International Institute for Environment and Development
strategies to tackle it extremely difficult to implement.
Despite these challenges, this is an opportunity to forge new partnerships between agencies that - if
they work together - can reach the populations in need.
High residential densities, with limited services
In informal settlements across the global South it is common for families of 2-5 people to live ina
single room shack or tenement block of around 3 metres by 4 metres. Shacks are often adjacent to
each other, with a single water tap and pit latrine shared between 5-10 families.
There is very limited public space for roads and pathways. The average population density of ‘slums’
in Nairobi, Kenya, was 28,200 people per square kilometre in 2009, a 51% increase in just ten years.
One large high-density informal settlement (Mukuru) has a population density of 108,128 people per
square kilometre (PDF). This makes it likely that the virus will spread rapidly.
Water supplies may be limited both because of the cost and because there is no access to piped
water within the dwelling or even the plot. In sub-Saharan Africa, access in urban areas to piped
water on the premises declined between 1990 and 2015.
And even when supplies are available, they are frequently intermittent in lower-income areas, and
they are frequently not affordable in the quantities required for good health. The World Health
Organization recommends 50 litres per person per day in non-emergency situations. This lack of
water makes it hard for frequent hand washing to take place.
Incomes are very low and savings non-existent
Most of the one billion people living in informal settlements have very little savings and nearly all
work in the informal economy, often as employees in informal enterprises or as micro-entrepreneurs
such as those selling vegetables. A small proportion have low paid jobs in the formal economy such as
cleaners, factory workers and guards.
Some of these households will be able to secure food from their extended family networks in rural
areas but many will not. Increased use of food from rural areas will require more movement and
potentially spread the disease.
It is extremely difficult for these workers to self-isolate; there is every likelihood they will carry on
working.
Many occupations are high risk
https:/Avww.iied.org/dealing-covid-19-towns-cities-global-south
2/8

3 Page 3

▲back to top


07/04/2020
Dealing with COVID-19 in the towns and cities of the global South | International Institute for Environment and Development
In addition to the considerable risks related to homes and neighbourhoods, many residents work in
high risk occupations. One example are waste recyclers and others working in waste-related
industry. There are also those who are paid to work in formal enterprises, such as cleaners, and who
are employed as domestic servants in higher-income neighbourhoods.
There may also be those who are teachers and nurses and who are exposed to large numbers of
people. Then there are the shop keepers and stall holders who have a constant interaction, generally
through cash, with many local people.
A lack of affordable health services
Formal health services are rare in most informal settlements. Even where these services do exist,
charges for medicine put them out of reach for many people. Households may supplement these
services with informal providers either because they do not trust the quality and/or because costs
are lower. In Mukuru, 100,500 households are served by 206 public and private (formal and
informal) health facilities.
The most common reason for urban households to shift from ‘just managing’ to chronic poverty Is ill
health. Health expenditures combined with the lack of income places severe strain on households.
There is a looming economic crisis
The scale of economic recession will have impacts on the global South. Incomes will fall even for
those who do not get sick with COVID-19. The Financial Times (22 March) summarised the current
state of economies in the global North and recorded that restaurant bookings globally are running
less than 95% of their total last year, while retail activities in the UK, Sweden, the United States and
Italy are 20-80% down. In China current power plant coal consumption is 30% below its level on 1
January 2020.
ln many countries in the global South there is no adequate programme to address emergency needs.
What needs to happen?
Despite these challenges, there is reason for optimism. Networks like Shack/Slum Dwellers
International (SDI) have been developing partnerships with local authorities to address development
needs in informal settlements for many years.
There is an immediate need to:
https:/Avww.iied.org/dealing-covid-19-towns-cities-global-south
3/8

4 Page 4

▲back to top


07/04/2020
Dealing with COVID-19 in the towns and cities of the global South | International Institute for Environment and Development
e Monitor conditions in informal and formal neighbourhoods across the globe. As seen by news
from Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, there is confusion and misinformation. SDI’s KnowYourCity data
collection programme already has much critical information and the systems in place to monitor
regularly. As government agencies learn from local communities what is happening on the ground
they will strengthen their relations with these groups, and help to build trust.
e Identify high-risk locations and help those individuals who are not well to isolate. Provide them
with access to emergency health services if required.
e Identify high-risk occupations and begin to roll out health programmes. These groups are
beginning to be organised and are reaching out to government. They need guidance and
protection.
e Establish effective partnerships between key stakeholders including organised citizens, national
and international government agencies, who are responsible for providing finance to those in
need, and who are responsible for providing essential services; and NGOs and professional
agencies able to provide technical assistance.
In cities such as Bulawayo, Zimbabwe, organised communities are changing the way that local
government thinks about informal neighbourhoods. In India, SDI’s Indian Alliance transformed
urban programming in some cities so that it was more effective in reaching local needs.
e Establish reliable sources of information so that people can act effectively to reduce risk and
protect lives.
e Work together - organised communities, local government and health ministries have to work
with one another to identify and test solutions to this crisis.
e Capacitate networks of community leaders (working both in neighbourhoods and specific
sectors) to share information that they collect upwards to the responsible agencies and share key
health messages downwards.
Local information translated into appropriate languages is now urgently needed. Muungano
help. Another is Abahlali baseMjondolo in Durban, South Africa.
Governance and the social contract are key
https:/Avww.iied.org/dealing-covid-19-towns-cities-global-south
4/8

5 Page 5

▲back to top


07/04/2020
Dealing with COVID-19 in the towns and cities of the global South | International Institute for Environment and Development
At the heart of ahumane progressive response will be anew relationship between citizens, their
organisations and the state. In this context, the state includes local and national government and
utilities. All have a critical role to play in responding to COVID-19.
In terms of the immediate health situation, many of the measures will be imposed on informal urban
communities. There is a risk that there will be a coercive militarised response. However, that will not
be enough to save lives. There is an urgent need for voluntary compliance with the required
measures and that means we need to identify, support and share experiments in governance that are
effective.
The experiences of networks like SDI is that trust can be built; there are many working in
government who have a good understanding of the needs of those living in informal settlements and
who understand the capabilities of community leaders. If trust is not established, misinformation and
fear will cause many additional problems.
In Asia, the last financial crisis was associated with large numbers returning to their rural homes,
which would potentially spread the virus to isolated areas with very few health services. There may
be food riots as economic conditions worsen and considerable health risks from malnutrition.
We need to identify measures that help communities respond to the economic crisis, with assistance
from social welfare departments and the humanitarian agencies. Once more, these interventions are
far more effective if they work with organised communities who can help identify those most in need
and help to develop approaches that build on existing capabilities and activities.
Further reading on IIED's work and the coronovirus
e Coronavirus and climate change are two crises that need humanity to unite, blog by Andrew
Norton
e Coronavirus threat looms large for low-income cities, blog by Eric Féevre and Cecilia Tacoli
This blog originally appeared on the Global Development Institute website
About the author
Diana Mitlin (diana.mitlin@iied.org) is principal researcher in IIED's Human
Settlements research group and professor of global urbanism at the Global
Development Institute
https:/Avwww.iied.org/dealing-covid-19-towns-cities-global-south
5/8

6 Page 6

▲back to top


07/04/2020
Dealing with COVID-19 in the towns and cities of the global South | International Institute for Environment and Development
Tags: Urban Matters, Informal settlements (slums), Shack/Slum Dwellers International (SDI),
Coronavirus, Zoonotic infectious diseases
= OQOO
All blogs | About the IIED blog | €) CC BY 4.0
URBAN MATTERS
Blogs integrating research and action for more inclusive and sustainable cities
Blog series
0 Comments _ International Institute for Environment and Development
oi Disqus' Privacy Policy
© Recommend
YtTweet f Share
6
Start the discussion...
a.
LOG IN WITH
OR SIGN UP WITH Disqus (?)
Name
© Login ~
Sort by Best ~
Be the first to comment.
(J subscribe © Add Disqus to your siteAdd DisqusAdd Do Not Sell My Data
https:/Avww.iied.org/dealing-covid-19-towns-cities-global-south
6/8

7 Page 7

▲back to top


07/04/2020
Dealing with COVID-19 in the towns and cities of the global South | International Institute for Environment and Development
Related blogs See all blogs
A world without refugee camps? ITED launches research on urban
refugees
6 April 2020
Despite COVID-19, using wild species may still be the best way to
i save them
1 April 2020
The world’s fastest growing cities
24 March 2020
Coronavirus and climate change are two crises that need humanity
to unite
13 March 2020
Coronavirus
The impact of COVID-19 on sustainable development. More in this collection
Despite COVID-19, using wild species may still be the best way to
i save them
Coronavirus and climate change are two crises that need humanity
to unite
Coronavirus threat looms large for low-income cities
https:/Avwww.iied.org/dealing-covid-19-towns-cities-global-south
7/8

8 Page 8

▲back to top


07/04/2020
Dealing with COVID-19 in the towns and cities of the global South | International Institute for Environment and Development
Contact us
People
Jobs and internships
Blogs
Events
Media centre
About
Our strategy
Our sites and networks
Accessibility
Privacy policy
Publications
IIED's mission is to build a fairer, more sustainable world, using evidence, action and influence in
partnership with others. We link local priorities to global challenges, and our 2019-2024 strategy details
how we will Make Change Happen
Sign up to our newsletters
y f You ©In
International Institute for Environment and Development, 80-86 Gray's Inn Road, London, WC1X 8NH, UK
Tel: +44 (0)20 3463 7399
Man.
back to top
https:/Avwww.iied.org/dealing-covid-19-towns-cities-global-south
8/8